Old Hickory Lake Practice report

After two days of fishing on Old Hickory there is one thing I know for certain, everything I've heard about Old Hickory Lake is true. This lake is inconsistent and difficult to develop a pattern and can be very frustrating. Yesterday, the first day of practice, I found a shell bed loaded with shad and proceeded to catch nine bass from the area no bigger than my boat, all on a Jackall Muscle Deep crankbait. Unfortunately, they were all 13 ¾" and on this lake they need to be 14" to be a keeper. Cranking is one of my favorite techniques so I proceeded to run that pattern for the next few hours…..not another bite. I did catch some more shorts doing various things, but never caught a keeper. Most places I checked out, both shallow and deep, had plenty of bait. Good cover, good structure, bait….yet no fish?

After a long day on the water, 5:30 am until 6:30 pm, I had dinner with two good friends of mine that I haven't seen in a while. They reminded me this is Old Hickory and not to get discouraged. Today I went out in a new frame of mind and just went fishing. To lighten up my mood I even had Pandora playing on my phone all day….hope my tournament partner likes Hayes Carll and the likes. The first spot I went to was a shallow hump on a main lake flat and the shad were spawning like crazy! In a fifteen minute span I caught two keepers including a 4lb smallmouth! I thought to myself "finally, I figured it out". Well, I was wrong. I've never seen a lake where bass can be ganged up in an area one minute and gone the next. Later in the day I went REAL shallow, kicking up mud with the trolling motor and caught a few more shorts and another keeper. The super shallow bite seems to be a fairly consistent pattern but I'm not the only one running that pattern and there are not enough shallow spots like this to hold up for a few days, especially with multiple anglers doing the same thing. This lake reminds me of one I fish often where the hotter it gets, the shallower the bass go. As hard as I tried to develop a deep ledge pattern, I just can't seem to get it to work.

My day ended with four keepers for about 10lbs, not a bad weight for Old Hickory, but I'm not sure I can duplicate it for three days. In practice, my goal is to cover water and see as much of the lake as possible. Come tournament time, I should have a few areas holding some fish but I really won't know the full potential until tournament day. It seems the best way to fish this lake is to keep an open mind and keep changing.

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Game & Fish stories delivered right to your inbox every week.