Why Contraceptives Will Not Work

Why Contraceptives Will Not Work
Because of the lack of hunting, deer have very few threats – other than vehicles. This allows them to age, and in the right conditions a whitetail can live up to 15 years in the wild. (Photo courtesy Joe Ciferno Photography)

Although many seek the wide-open rural landscapes or big woods for deer hunting, it likely will come to no surprise to many of us that there are some “thick” deer populations in many suburban and even urban areas.

From Chicago to Pittsburgh to even Manhattan, deer populations can get “out of check” fast without the ability to control them through normal methods, like hunting. However, with most of these areas being dominated by non-hunters, it is difficult to convince local citizens of the need to have hunting to control these deer populations, especially with the hot topic of “alternative control methods,” or more specifically sharpshooting or contraceptives.

Sharpshooting is a whole other topic. It might sound crazy but many non-hunting citizens seem to welcome sharpshooting as a control method rather than controlled bowhunting.

Really?


We won’t get into that this time. The more overwhelming non-hunting public is in favor of contraceptive methods. These can include immunocontraceptives, like the USDA approved GonaCon™, a vaccine-applied hormone that reduces a deer’s ability to release other hormones necessary for breeding; or physical contraceptives like the intense “spaying projects” being performed by veterinarians in Fairfax County, Va. (Washington D.C. area) and the East Hamptons.


I’m not going to rip these apart for “not working.” In fact as a student at Penn State, I worked on and completed an entire semester’s side project on the effects of immunocontraceptive drugs on whitetail at the University’s Deer Research Unit. I’m also not going to harp on the cost, which is expensive, or how much labor is actually involved in applying one of these methods, which is a lot.

Small pockets of woods can hold many deer, usually more than the habitat can truly support. At this point, deer start to “vandalize” gardens and bird feeders in neighborhoods. Though not much, these small woodlots can be great areas for controlled archery hunts, to remove deer in a safe and ethical manner. (Emily Flinn photo)
Small pockets of woods can hold many deer, usually more than the habitat can truly support. At this point, deer start to “vandalize” gardens and bird feeders in neighborhoods. Though not much, these small woodlots can be great areas for controlled archery hunts, to remove deer in a safe and ethical manner. (Emily Flinn photo)

No, this article is simply to illustrate why, as a professional deer biologist, I do not believe either contraceptive method will manage deer populations to the appropriate densities.

Let’s remember where and why these are even being discussed. The areas are already at high deer densities. With many whitetail being able to live up to 15 years of age (in free-range conditions) without hunting, regardless of whether you treat every doe in the area, you still have too many deer. Contraceptives may control the population from growing more, but the problem already exists. The solution is removing deer from the herd. This is where hunting comes into play, and for the long haul.

As you remove deer from an area like this, and surrounding herds that are not being managed as intensely “catch wind,” you pose to be a candidate for the “sponge effect.” If you take a moist sponge and place it in a bowl of water it will soak up more water until capacity is reached. Well, when deer are removed from an area, and the resources and space in that area are better than surrounding areas, other deer will move in to absorb those available resources. This is why consistent management is necessary. Even if the herd at hand isn’t reproducing, surrounding herds likely are which provides the immigration source to keep the herd under contraceptive management at a stable (and HIGH) population.


So I am not saying that the contraceptives won’t work. Actually, it’s proven that they will. But proven to manage deer fertility and proven to manage free-ranging whitetail numbers are two different things. I do not see the methods being able to manage herds themselves. It will require sharpshooting and/or controlled hunting in conjunction to be an effective management tool.

In the end, hunting is still the most effective management tool we have available when used correctly, whether in the city or in the woods.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Kevin VanDam Fishing Reels from Lew

Kevin VanDam Fishing Reels from Lew's

The Kevin VanDam LFS Baitcast reel ($139.99) comes in three models (6.2:1, 7.5:1, 8.3:1), with right- and left-hand retrieve, 10-bearing system with Zero Reverse one-way clutch, aluminum frame and spool, carbon fiber drag system, up to 20 pounds drag power.

Shimano Vanford Spinning Reel

Shimano Vanford Spinning Reel

In-Fisherman's Managing Editor, Rob Neuman, sits down with bass pro Josh Douglas, to get insight on the all-new ShimanoVanford spinning reel. It features a LongStroke Spool for long-distance casting. The Vanford spinning reel will be available in 7 sizes: 500-5000. MSRP: $299.99 - $239.99.

Portable Hornady Rapid Safes - Security on the Water

Portable Hornady Rapid Safes - Security on the Water

Hornady Security has a new line of portable safes with applications for anglers who want to have a firearm on board their boats, just in case.

Engel

Engel's High Viz Drybox Coolers

Versatile boxes available in four sizes; ICAST Fishing Gear Guide.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Here are the 10 most common spinning and baitcaster reel performance problems and how to fix them. Fishing How-To

10 Most Common Reel Performance Problems

Anietra Hamper

Here are the 10 most common spinning and baitcaster reel performance problems and how to fix...

While catfish are still catfish, the difference between day and night tactics and strategies can be profound, even when fishing the same lake or river. Fishing How-To

How to Catch Catfish Day and Night

Terry Madewell

While catfish are still catfish, the difference between day and night tactics and strategies...

We found 10 secret (and proven) catfish baits that have the staying power to attract catfish time after time. Catfish

10 Secret Catfish Baits You Didn't Know About

Anietra Hamper

We found 10 secret (and proven) catfish baits that have the staying power to attract catfish...

Want to test the outer limits of your shooting skill? There's more to successful long-range Ammo

10 Best Long-Range Cartridges Ever Made

David Hart - January 14, 2015

Want to test the outer limits of your shooting skill? There's more to successful long-range

See More Trending Articles

More Whitetail

It's not over after the deer rut, and your best whitetail hunting may still be ahead. Whitetail

Make Late Season the Great Season

Mark Chesnut

It's not over after the deer rut, and your best whitetail hunting may still be ahead.

He found his 19-point 'buck' to be a doe as he started field-dressing. Whitetail

Missouri Hunter Bags Rare Antlered Doe

G&F Online Staff - December 02, 2019

He found his 19-point 'buck' to be a doe as he started field-dressing.

Could a new testing protocol lead to the repeal of bans on urine-based scents for deer hunting? Conservation & Politics

Perspective: Urine-Based Scent Use for Deer Hunting

Adam Heggenstaller - December 19, 2019

Could a new testing protocol lead to the repeal of bans on urine-based scents for deer hunting?

Learn the lingo to improve your odds in the whitetail woods. Whitetail

8 Deer Vocalizations You Must Master

Mike Marsh

Learn the lingo to improve your odds in the whitetail woods.

See More Whitetail

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Game & Fish subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now