Skip to main content

Where Have All the Big Bluegills Gone?

In many Upper Midwest lakes, the average size of bluegills has decreased. Is selective harvest to blame?

Where Have All the Big Bluegills Gone?

Studies show large male bluegills should be released to pass along their large-bodied, fast-growing characteristics. (Photo by Scott Mackenthun)

At an annual gathering of fisheries researchers, scientists, managers and students, Dennis Pratt gave one of his final talks as a biologist for the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources prior to his retirement. Best known for his work with trout and salmon in Lake Superior and its tributaries, Pratt switched gears and took the opportunity to talk about the astonishing lack of large bluegills in the state of Wisconsin.

His message was simple: Large bluegills needed some help and attention. The small crowd of fisheries professionals in the audience nodded their heads in agreement as he spoke.

To illustrate his point, Pratt reviewed bluegill data from Wisconsin’s survey database and discovered that you'd have a better chance of being dealt a royal flush in a hand of five-card stud— 649,739-to-1 odds—than catching a bluegill over 10 inches on a random Wisconsin lake. That simple statistic framed a vexing reality: Big bluegills have long been rare creatures, but in modern times they are all but gone.

The disappearance of large bluegills isn’t unique to Wisconsin. Old panfish anglers recall stories of the big-bluegill glory days of their past, and they fit with observations gleaned from regional datasets. Studies in Minnesota, Wisconsin and Nebraska have documented large-fish declines in historic catch, either with statewide survey records or winning entries in long-running fishing contests. Other Midwestern states have similar observations or likely would if their datasets were more robust and went back far enough.


Reasons for the Decline

By their nature, big bluegills are susceptible to overharvest. Their gregarious schooling tendencies cluster the fish in prime habitats where anglers can easily find and catch them. Their curiosity and need to forage for large numbers of insects and big-bodied zooplankton make them willing biters. Their spawning strategies make them especially vulnerable. Bluegills, like other sunfish, begin spawning over nests in shallow water in late spring. They often occupy similar locations from year to year. With no closed season on bluegills on most Midwestern waters, male bluegills are easily caught and removed.


Male bluegills exhibit alternative life-history strategies. Large "parental" males delay sexual maturity, which allows them to devote their energy resources to growth rather than reproduction. In contrast, some smaller males can operate as cuckolds. They sneak in to spawn unfertilized eggs in a "sneaker" role. A small male can also pass as a female by way of its smaller body size and lighter coloration. These fish will sometimes squeeze between a spawning female and parental male in a "satellite" male role, fertilizing eggs in the process.

Midwest Bluegills
When large parental males are removed, inferior males fertilize eggs. Their traits decrease the average size of fish in the area. (Photo by Scott Mackenthun)

Both sneaker and satellite males can be sexually mature as young as two or three years of age, whereas parental males will delay sexual maturity until age six or seven. Sneaker and satellite males provide no parental care. Parental males excavate spawning nests and work to guard the nest and eggs by running off predators and other competing males. When anglers harvest parental males, they remove fish that are critical to ensuring that large-bodied, fast-growing genes are passed to the next generation. Removing the largest bluegills in a lake, as many anglers hungry for a meal are wont to do, takes out a disproportionate number of critically important parental males, not just during the spawn, but throughout the year.

For years, bluegill anglers interpreted selective harvest as keeping the largest fish and releasing smaller fish to grow to larger sizes. In doing so, they took out the fastest-growing and largest-bodied fish. They also removed the oldest fish. Midwestern bluegills can grow as old as 10 to 12 years, which might be an underestimation. Put simply, it takes time to grow large bluegills, and when harvest is high, there isn’t enough time, or enough other large fish coming up, to replace the big fish that are removed.

What Now?

Because bluegills have been available to Midwestern anglers—and so easily caught—for so long, they have been a staple of fish fries for generations. As such, attempts to regulate harvest have been historically unpopular. But attitudes might be changing. Recent human dimension surveys in Minnesota have documented angler dissatisfaction with the small size of bluegills. It appears that anglers are willing to give up some of their bag limit if they can catch larger fish. A quarter-century of research into bluegill dynamics across the Midwest by state biologists and academics has shown that only very drastic cuts to bag limits are enough to produce meaningful results that maintain or improve large bluegill sizes.


In 2018, North Dakota cut its bag and possession limit in half. South Dakota is collecting data on a set of big-bluegill waters to see how much harvest is occurring. It could consider regulations if harvest of large bluegills is identified as a problem. In Wisconsin and Minnesota, lakes with reduced bag limits are producing large bluegills, and there are proposals to add more waters to a growing list. Preliminary public support in Minnesota and Wisconsin has been favorable—quite a contrast to similar proposals just a decade earlier. In other states, enacting a limit on public waters will be a first step. Kansas, Illinois, Indiana and Ohio do not have any bag or size limits on bluegills.

Anglers who value large bluegills will need to do their part. To have big bluegills in the future, they will need to exercise restraint by releasing bluegills more than 8 inches in length and keeping only smaller fish. They also need to support more restrictive regulations proposed by management agencies. Even with biological justification, social opposition can squash useful regulations.

As modern fishing technology increasingly gives anglers the upper hand, now more than ever, discretion and responsible use is critical through selective harvest that releases the largest fish in the population. Without regulated or voluntary release of large bluegills, Midwestern bull bluegills on many waters won’t be available for the next generation of anglers.


Get Your Fish On.

Plan your next fishing and boating adventure here.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Hobie MirageDrive 360 Kayak Propulsion: Amazing Control and Power

Hobie MirageDrive 360 Kayak Propulsion: Amazing Control and Power

The Hobie MirageDrive 360 pedal propulsion system is the pinnacle of kayak control with more efficient fin designs, glide technology and allows the boat to be moved in any direction.

Catch More Bass on a Jerkbait in the Cooler Months

Catch More Bass on a Jerkbait in the Cooler Months

This one simple trick will trigger more bass strikes on a jerkbait during the fall months.

Understanding Reel Retrieve Ratios and How it Affects Lure Presentations

Understanding Reel Retrieve Ratios and How it Affects Lure Presentations

Increase a lure’s effectiveness by pairing it with the ideal reel speed.

Action and Power Ratings- How to Choose the Right Bass Rod

Action and Power Ratings- How to Choose the Right Bass Rod

Most fishing rods feature both an action and a power rating, but what do those ratings mean and how do you use them to select the right rod for different scenarios? In this video, outdoor writer and tackle specialist Shane Beilue breaks down the difference between a rod blank’s action and power and discusses what the various ratings of each mean.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Celebrate with great food for your backyard BBQ or picnic with these outdoor recipes.10 Recipes for Your Backyard Get Together Wild Game

10 Recipes for Your Backyard Get Together

Game & Fish Online Staff

Celebrate with great food for your backyard BBQ or picnic with these outdoor recipes.

Quick look at common, easy-to-catch fish species (video).Get On Board: Species 101 for Beginning Anglers Other Freshwater

Get On Board: Species 101 for Beginning Anglers

Game & Fish Staff

Quick look at common, easy-to-catch fish species (video).

We found 10 secret (and proven) catfish baits that have the staying power to attract catfish time after time.10 Secret Catfish Baits You Didn't Know About Catfish

10 Secret Catfish Baits You Didn't Know About

Anietra Hamper

We found 10 secret (and proven) catfish baits that have the staying power to attract catfish...

Make this venison chorizo recipe and cook it right away or freeze it (cooked or raw) and use it as needed.Venison Chorizo Recipe Wild Game

Venison Chorizo Recipe

Allie Doran - October 30, 2020

Make this venison chorizo recipe and cook it right away or freeze it (cooked or raw) and use...

See More Trending Articles

More Panfish

Maximize your panfish effort by simplifying your setup.Bobber Your Way to Bluegills Panfish

Bobber Your Way to Bluegills

Darl Black - May 12, 2020

Maximize your panfish effort by simplifying your setup.

Here's everything you need to know to load a stringer with slabs under the lights.Work the Night Shift for After-Dark Crappies Panfish

Work the Night Shift for After-Dark Crappies

Terry Madewell - August 18, 2020

Here's everything you need to know to load a stringer with slabs under the lights.

There is no single magic bullet for managing up-and-down crappie populations.How ‘Boom or Bust' Impacts Crappie Population Panfish

How ‘Boom or Bust' Impacts Crappie Population

Carolee Anita Boyles - April 09, 2020

There is no single magic bullet for managing up-and-down crappie populations.

In many Upper Midwest lakes, the average size of bluegills has decreased. Is selective harvest to blame?Where Have All the Big Bluegills Gone? Panfish

Where Have All the Big Bluegills Gone?

Scott Mackenthun - July 30, 2020

In many Upper Midwest lakes, the average size of bluegills has decreased. Is selective harvest...

See More Panfish

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Game & Fish App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Game & Fish subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now