Kriet's Birthday Miracle

Catch, release and catch pays off big for Kriet and partner

Kriet's Birthday Miracle
Jeff Kriet and Gene Eisenmann show off part of their 31-pound stringer in a Lake Murray event. (Courtesy Jeff Kriet)

It wasn’t a world record, but the 11-pounder Jeff Kriet netted May 19 turned out to be a pretty special birthday present.

To understand the significance of the catch, it’s necessary to start at the beginning, two years ago. On April 6, 2010, Jeff Kriet went fun fishing on Lake Murray with Gene Eisenmann, a friend of his. He found and caught a giant bass bedding on top of a stump, and Eisenmann encouraged him to have it weighed.

“I was just going to let it go,” Kriet said. “My buddy Gene told me I needed to weigh it.”

The behemoth tipped the scales at 12.12 pounds and was certified as the new lake record.


“After they certified it, I wanted to leave it in the marina, because you can’t fish in there,” Kriet said. “So I let it go right there next to the gas dock thinking maybe we would get at least one good spawn out of her.”


Fast forward to May 19, Kriet’s birthday, and he and Eisenmann loaded up to fish a small tournament on Lake Murray. He was able to get out the day before the derby and found one offshore hump that seemed promising.

“I pulled up on that deal first thing in the morning and caught a 3-pounder,” Kriet said. “75 percent of the time that will be big bass. The next one we caught was an 11-something. I netted it and got lined back up and caught a 9.”

Before he could catch his breath, Kriet and Eisenmann had compiled a jaw-dropping 31-pound stringer, something unheard of on Lake Murray.

“I figure catching a 31-pound sack there is like catching a 60-pound sack on Falcon,” Kriet said. “It’s just unheard of. There was a jackpot last night and it probably took 7 or 8 pounds to win. It’s one of those lakes where if you catch over 10 pounds, you have a chance to win. There are some big fish in there, but they are just random. And I caught those fish on back-to-back throws.”


His biggest stringer previously there was around 21 or 22 pounds and they topped that by nearly 10. Second place was 11.5 pounds, the size of Eisenmann’s one fish. The other anglers in the tournament were left shaking their heads. How else do you explain such an occurrence other than calling it a birthday miracle?

“They can’t get mad – that’s so unheard of on that lake,” Kriet said. “It was just one of those fluke deals where everything lined up – I don’t know if it will ever be done again.”

The real surprise came later that day when he received a call from Eisenmann.


When they started looking back and comparing pictures of the 12.12 Kriet caught in 2010 and the 11-pounder Eisenmann boated in the tournament, the fish looked identical. The telling mark was a black dot on the jaw of the fish reminiscent of Dottie, the 25-pounder caught in California.

There is no doubt in either of the two anglers’ minds that it was the same fish. Kriet was floored that his catch-and-release tactics from two years ago paid off.

“I was just blown away – catch and release sure works,” Kriet said. “It was probably only a mile and a half from where I caught her the first time and only a mile and a half from the marina where she was released.

“That was an awesome birthday present. It was just a fishing day I’ll never forget.”

Dottie 2.0 still swims in the waters of Lake Murray after another successful release by Kriet and Eisenmann.

“Maybe I’ll get lucky,” Kriet said, “and catch her again two years from now.”

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Tackle Test 2020: Shakespeare Ugly Stik Carbon

Tackle Test 2020: Shakespeare Ugly Stik Carbon

Tackle Test 2020: Shakespeare Ugly Stik Carbon

Get on Board: Species for Beginner Anglers

Get on Board: Species for Beginner Anglers

With so many people turning to fishing as a way to escape the stress and challenges that have arisen in recent months, we've teamed up with the Recreational Boating and Fishing Foundation and the National Marine Manufacturers Association to explore some of the freshwater fish species you can target if you're just getting on board with fishing. #TheWaterIsOpen #GetOnBoard

G Loomis NRX Rods

G Loomis NRX Rods

Whatever the target species, these rods feel good in the fly shop when you're giving them a test drive.

Tactacam Fish-I Camera and Remote

Tactacam Fish-I Camera and Remote

Recording your fishing success is a one-button deal with Tactacam's FISH-I Camera and Remote. Tactacam's Ben Sterns shares insight on the camera system with In-Fisherman's Todd Ceisner as part of our 2020 ICAST New Fishing Gear Guide.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

If you haven't looked at the smaller urban lakes in your area, you are missing out on some great bass pond fishing. Bass

Bass Pond Fishing: Catch Lunkers at Small Lakes Near You

Dan Anderson

If you haven't looked at the smaller urban lakes in your area, you are missing out on some...

As most catfish anglers know, blue cats, channel cats and flatheads will eat darn near anything that fits in their mouths. Catfish

5 Ways To Catch Catfish on Lures

Keith Sutton

As most catfish anglers know, blue cats, channel cats and flatheads will eat darn near...

Almost anyone can catch a bunch of small catfish. Hooking a true monster requires a different level of preparation, skill and effort. Catfish

A Time for Giant Catfish

John N. Felsher - August 24, 2020

Almost anyone can catch a bunch of small catfish. Hooking a true monster requires a different...

Sight Savvy: Different styles of bow sights each have their strengths—and weaknesses. Bows

How to Pick the Right Bow Sight for You

Tony Hansen - August 25, 2020

Sight Savvy: Different styles of bow sights each have their strengths—and weaknesses.

See More Trending Articles

More Stories

Pan-friend slabs may not sound like a holiday meal, but as a celebration of Mom's life it was my most memorable Christmas dinner ever. Stories

Crappie for Christmas: The Fondest of Childhood Memories

Keith Sutton - December 19, 2018

Pan-friend slabs may not sound like a holiday meal, but as a celebration of Mom's life it was...

Cabela's agrees to be bought by Bass Pro Shops in a deal valued at $5.5 billion that will combine the top two hunting and fishing retailers in the United States Stories

Bass Pro Shops 'Reels In' Cabela's with $5.5 Billion Deal

Abhijith Ganapavaram and Sruthi Shankar

Cabela's agrees to be bought by Bass Pro Shops in a deal valued at $5.5 billion that will...

Major League Fishing (MLF), a made-for-television bass fishing competition featuring the country's top professional anglers, celebrates its 5-year anniversary this summer with news it has become the No. 1 fishing show in the nation. Stories

Major League Fishing Celebrates 5-Year Anniversary with Top Rating

MLF Communications

Major League Fishing (MLF), a made-for-television bass fishing competition featuring the...

The The eastern Georgia lake may be best known for its bass, but anglers will find more trophies in these waters than just largemouths. Georgia lake may be best known for its bass, but anglers will find more trophies in these waters than just largemouths. Fishing

Chase a Mixed-Bag Bite at Lake Oconee

Larry Larsen - April 28, 2020

The The eastern Georgia lake may be best known for its bass, but anglers will find more...

See More Stories

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Game & Fish subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now