Skip to main content Skip to main content

'Biggest Deer I've Ever Killed'

Ohio hunter nearly in tears after taking buck nearing 200

'Biggest Deer I've Ever Killed'
Jason Erb poses with his Ohio bruiser that approached 200 inches. (Courtesy Jason Erb)

Jason Erb’s longtime friend, an avid turkey hunter, referred to the whitetail deer on his property as “woods carp,” even the trophy ones.

Deer, he said, only got in the way for the pursuit of his beloved gobblers.

“He’s a huge turkey hunter,” Erb said. “(Deer) are a nuisance to him. We go turkey hunting all the time and we can see 140-, 150-inch deer, and he’ll just go, ‘Yeah, that’s nice.’ They mess up his turkey hunting.”

But even he was impressed by the monster buck Erb harvested on the property in early November.

Erb, 41, a mechanical engineer from Alliance, Ohio, dropped the behemoth 16-pointer during the final minutes of legal shooting light on Nov. 3. Its spread measured 25 5/8 inches on the inside, 27 ½ on the outside. After the mandatory 60-day drying period, its official gross score was 193-0, 175-0 net.

“Biggest deer I’ve ever killed,” he said, “and probably the biggest I’ll ever kill.”

Erb had made plans to hunt on his friend’s property that covered 600-plus acres in Columbiana County, which borders Pennsylvania in northeastern Ohio. An avid bow hunter, Erb hoped to spend as much time as possible in the woods throughout the hunting season.

“I asked my wife and I asked my boss, ‘I want to hunt as much as I can without getting divorced or fired,’ ” Erb said. “So every night I would leave (work) 45 minutes early, leaving the office at about 3:15. I would get in my truck, drive 45 minutes south of here and I would go sit in my tree.”

When he was setting his tree stand before the season, Erb was given a hint of things to come.

“I saw a deer in the field that was bigger than anything I’ve ever seen in my life, probably 400 yards away from me,” he said. “And to be honest, this might have been that deer. Still don’t know. If not, there is another big one down there.”

With a goal of shooting something in the 130 to 150 range – he had seen several on game cams set in the area – Erb hunted hard throughout the early portion of the season. Even though warmer temperatures kept him out of the woods for several days, the afternoon of Nov. 3 was his 17th day in the stand for the season.

“It was a Sunday evening,” he said. “My wife and daughters went to some play, so I said, ‘You know what? I’m going to go sit in the woods.’

“It was sunny out. There wasn’t a squirrel moving, nothing. I’m texting a couple buddies, ‘This is beautiful out here, but this stinks.’ Not even a leaf is moving.”

Sitting in a small field surrounded by woods on the first afternoon after the fall time change, there was less than a half hour of light remaining when a doe and two yearlings stepped into the field. While the youngsters monkeyed around, the doe checked out most of the field.

“She never looked up, just walked the field,” Erb said. “She gets about 10 yards away from me, tucks her tail and walks away pretty quick.

“I’ve been in the woods long enough to know something’s coming. Something made her do that and I know it wasn’t me. I know an ‘Oh crap. I smell something that doesn’t belong here.’ I know what that looks like. So I knew a buck was coming.”

Even before seeing the buck, Erb turned his Bear Attack compound bow vertical and positioned his TRU-Ball T-handle release and half-drew.

The buck first shows himself about 40 yards away, but Erb cannot see horns. It approaches a scrape about 35 yards from Erb, raises its neck and licks a limb underneath scrape.

“Now I can tell he is wide, but I can’t tell what he is,” he said.

The buck continues toward the tree stand, approaching the yearlings. At about 20 yards, he turns broadside to Erb, who is now certain it is a shooter buck. An accomplished shooter who participates in 3-D tournaments during the summer months, Erb is confident in the shot and takes it.

“I let go and everybody scatters,” he said. “Usually I don’t get down right away from my stand, but I knew everything was far enough away. The shot was 18 yards and I find two-thirds of my arrow snapped off right there. There’s a puddle of blood, so I’m good.”

He returns to his truck and waits 45 minutes, killing the time by texting buddies. He then grabs his flashlights and begins to trail the deer.

“I go back … blood, blood, blood. It’s not like I had to look very hard,” Erb said. “I’m on my track, looking up, trying to find a belly. I see a log up there and walk a little bit further. I turned back and that log wasn’t a log. It was a belly. He went about 80 yards.”

Biggest Deer I've Ever Killed

What was before him was astonishing to behold. Lying on its side, the buck’s antlers reached nearly to Erb’s upper thigh. He called his friend the landowner for assistance removing the deer.

“I get off the phone and I don’t have anyone but me and the deer,” he said. “I’ll be honest with you, I’m almost crying. I’ve finally got that kind of deer. I’ve lost deer. I lost a deer 10 days before this one and it makes you sick to the point where you want to quit hunting. You feel bad for the animal whether he’s living or not.

“I’m kneeling over my deer, counting points … 9 on one side, 7 on the other. In my mind, he’s around 170 inches. So I text a couple of pictures to some buddies, and they’re like, ‘No, no, no. He’s close to 200 inches.’”At that point, the landowner arrived on his side-by-side ATV.

“It wasn’t a woods carp anymore,” Erb said. “It was the biggest deer he had ever seen in his entire life.”

Go to Deer Camp

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

Popular Videos

Beyond the Bait: How to Choose and Fish Crankbaits for Smallmouth

Beyond the Bait: How to Choose and Fish Crankbaits for Smallmouth

Crankbaits excel for smallmouth bass not only in lakes and reservoirs but also in waters with current, such as rivers. Fishing a crankbait is straightforward, but there's more to it than just casting and reeling. In this episode of Beyond the Bait, we'll go over how to choose the right crankbait based on water depth and other conditions, as well as how to fish it effectively for smallmouth bass.

A Look at the Lupo

A Look at the Lupo

In the second episode of Beyond the Rifle, we'll discuss the innovation behind the major components of the Lupo. Just how unique is this new rifle? Prepare yourself for some surprises.

Umarex The Modern Air Rifle: Air Archery with the Umarex AirJavelin

Umarex The Modern Air Rifle: Air Archery with the Umarex AirJavelin

The AirJavelin takes airpower into a whole new direction, with no strings attached. Powered by CO2, it launches a 170-grain arrow at 300 fps. With a full-length Picatinny rail on top and a short section below the barrel, it can be accessorized to the hilt. So, if you're interested in launching dozens of arrows downrange without ever pulling a bowstring, consider the Umarex AirJavelin.

See All Videos

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!


Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services


Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Game & Fish App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Game & Fish stories delivered right to your inbox every week.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Game & Fish subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now