Bear Necessities for Proper Management

Bear-hunting regulations vary widely throughout the West. Are these differences necessary?

Bear Necessities for Proper Management

Black bears are among the least seen and most difficult species to monitor and manage, so many state game agencies tend to err on the side of caution when it comes to seasons and hunting regulations. (Shutterstock image)

No big-game hunt in the West differs as much from state to state as black bear hunting. It’s legal to use both bait and hounds in Utah, for instance, but only spot-and-stalk hunting is permitted in Montana. Washington allows hunters to take two bears per year, but Nevada distributes its limited bear tags by lottery and successful permittees are required to graduate from an “indoctrination” class before they actually receive their tag.

Why are bears the subjects of such close and variable regulatory scrutiny? The answer is both predictable—more than other wildlife species, black bears are relatable to non-hunters, who ascribe to them human traits and try to protect them through legislation—and surprising. Because black bears are among the least seen and most difficult species to monitor and manage, many state game agencies tend to err on the side of caution when it comes to seasons and hunting regulations.

Take California. The Golden State is Patient Zero when it comes to ballot-box biology. California voters used a citizen initiative to outlaw all mountain lion hunting in the state, and last year the legislature approved a law banning all fur trapping. There was a precedent for this pattern of legislating wildlife management. In 2012, SB 1221 outlawed hound hunting for black bears. If the stated intention of that law was to end what proponents called “unfair” to the bears and bobcats being pursued by hounds and “cruel” to the dogs themselves, which they claimed were often mauled by the quarry or exhausted by the hunt, the result has been that fewer black bears are killed in California now than prior to the hound prohibition.

And, as you might have predicted, California’s black bears have been growing in number and expanding their range ever since. In fact, since the hound-hunting closure, both bear depredation reports and kill permits have increased nearly twofold.


California manages its hunting season on the basis of a quota. The season closes on the last Sunday in December or when 1,500 bears are killed, whichever comes first. Prior to the 2012 hound prohibition, the quota was 1,700 bears, and in most years the quota was met, with about half the kill attributed to hound hunters. Since 2012, the harvest has been closer to an average of 1,200 bears, despite the California Department of Fish and Game’s estimate of a statewide population of nearly 36,000 bears, and growing.


BAIT, HOUNDS AND TRAPS

To understand why black bears are such lightning rods for public scrutiny, it’s useful to consider their history across the West. Originally, they weren’t classified as game animals at all. While deer, elk, bighorn sheep and moose all received protection as species managed by hunting seasons, bears were lumped with coyotes, cougars and bobcats as predators undeserving of protection by state wildlife agencies. It was legal to kill them by any means necessary, including by trapping, across most Western states all the way up until the middle of the last century.

As sportsmen began to consider bears as worthy quarry, protections afforded other game species followed. Seasons, bag limits and requirements to salvage meat and hides started to be applied to black bears. But across the West, baiting and hunting with hounds remained legal in most states. That started to change as the non-hunting public—their imaginations sparked by such popular icons as Teddy Bears, Paddington Bear and the U.S. Forest Service’s Smokey Bear—considered hunting bears to be both barbaric and unnecessary.

You can track the adoption of most restrictions on baiting and hounds to states with a vocal and growing majority of non-hunters in the electorate. California, Oregon, Washington and Nevada all adopted some restrictions on black bear hunting. Currently, none of those four states allow bear hunters to use either bait or dogs.

Western Bears
Baiting is an extremely effective way to hunt bears, but outcry from non-hunters has caused several Western states to ban the method. (Photo by Andrew McKean)

In states with a more rural and hunter-friendly electorate, black bear regulations often allow for the use of both bait and hounds. Montana is a notable exception, but its conservative bear-hunting rules are explained by the presence of grizzlies, which might be attracted to and habituated by baits.


So, how have bear populations responded to restrictions on hunting methods in those states? It’s a little hard to generalize, as bear habitats vary widely in all four states, but in general, populations are stable to increasing.

Oregon reckons its statewide black bear population at between 25,000 and 30,000. Washington, which allows hunters to take two bears a year, pegs its statewide bear population at around 25,000. Nevada, which has only limited bear habitat, doesn’t provide a statewide census but says most mountain ranges in the western part of the state host several hundred bears. But California’s trend seems to be shared by neighboring states: Bears are increasing in numbers and range. As they do, the number of incidents in which bear-human conflict is reported increases as well.

“Over the years, reported human-bear conflicts have increased significantly,” says Vicky Monroe, California’s Wildlife Conflict Programs Coordinator. “Each spring and summer we receive numerous calls from the public reporting anything from black bears eating food off campground picnic tables to bears taking dips in residential swimming pools.”


In fact, since hound hunting was prohibited in California, the number of bears killed on depredation tags—those issued to resolve “problem bear” cases—increased from an average of 64 per year to nearly 98 per year.

BEAR MANAGEMENT PHILOSOPHIES

In general, bears are considered difficult to both count and manage. That’s because, unlike elk or deer, they don’t congregate in herds. They are relatively solitary, and they prefer to stay in cover and avoid humans.

As a result, hunting bears isn’t so much a population-management necessity as it is a way to provide opportunity for hunters. Across the West, spring bear seasons provide rare big-game hunting opportunities, and not just for resident hunters.

That opportunity-first management philosophy explains why so many states allow relatively liberal means of take. Alaska, Idaho, Utah and Wyoming all allow either the use of baits or hounds to hunt black bears.

Game managers explain the regulations on the basis of tradition and efficacy. In other words, we’ve always done it that way, and it’s hard to kill black bears without the aid of dogs or donuts.

In Wyoming, which reports a stable-to-slowly-increasing black bear population, 81 percent of spring bears are taken over baits, compared with only 18 percent of the total harvest taken over bait in the fall season. Game managers report that far fewer female bears are taken in the spring season, largely because hunters are more selective, and have more time and opportunity to scrutinize bears over bait, as opposed to the often rushed encounter that hunters can have when stalking or ambushing bears.

Because of the difficulty in tracking bear populations and the wide variety of social concerns among various Western states with huntable bear populations, bear-hunting regulations are likely to continue to change over time. What’s unlikely is that these changes will result in more uniform regulations from state to state.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Yakgear Basic Kayak Angler & Deluxe Anchor Trolley Kits

Yakgear Basic Kayak Angler & Deluxe Anchor Trolley Kits

New products from ICAST 2020 included the Yakgear Basic Kayak Angler and Deluxe Anchor Trolley kits. Bill Bragman highlights the features of each kit.

Tackle Test 2020: Postcards from Mexico

Tackle Test 2020: Postcards from Mexico

A behind-the-scenes look at our bass-fishing gear reviews from Lake Picachos.

Rapala OG Slim 6

Rapala OG Slim 6

The 2019 Bassmaster Classic champ Ott Defoe sits down with In-Fisherman Associate Publisher Todd Ceisner, to talk about Rapala's new OG Slim 6 crankbait. The OG Slim 6 will feature a flat-sided, balsa body, and will dive around 6 feet. Featuring a circuit board lip, the OG Slim 6 deflects off of cover better than traditional plastic lips. Offered in 14 colors and available in tackle stores Fall 2020. MSRP $10.99.

Bubba Blade: Multi-Flex Interchangeable Blade Set

Bubba Blade: Multi-Flex Interchangeable Blade Set

Four blades in versatile knife system to fit your needs; ICAST Fishing Gear Guide.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

The colder waters of early spring are prime times to use these proven bait rigs for stripers. Striper & Hybrid

3 Proven Bait Rigs for Stripers

J.B. Kasper

The colder waters of early spring are prime times to use these proven bait rigs for stripers.

If you haven't looked at the smaller urban lakes in your area, you are missing out on some great bass pond fishing. Bass

Bass Pond Fishing: Catch Lunkers at Small Lakes Near You

Dan Anderson

If you haven't looked at the smaller urban lakes in your area, you are missing out on some...

Field Skills: Want to be a better shooter? The first step is perfecting your release. Hunting How-To

6 Steps to the Perfect Trigger Pull on Your Compound Bow

Jace Bauserman - August 27, 2020

Field Skills: Want to be a better shooter? The first step is perfecting your release.

As most catfish anglers know, blue cats, channel cats and flatheads will eat darn near anything that fits in their mouths. Catfish

5 Ways To Catch Catfish on Lures

Keith Sutton

As most catfish anglers know, blue cats, channel cats and flatheads will eat darn near...

See More Trending Articles

More Big Game

Sight Savvy: Different styles of bow sights each have their strengths—and weaknesses. Bows

How to Pick the Right Bow Sight for You

Tony Hansen - August 25, 2020

Sight Savvy: Different styles of bow sights each have their strengths—and weaknesses.

Field skills: Here's how to find more game with binoculars every time. Hunting How-To

The Right Way — Some Wrong Ways, Too — to Glass for Big Game

Bob Robb - September 04, 2020

Field skills: Here's how to find more game with binoculars every time.

Here's where the experts think hunters will find the biggest bulls this season. Big Game

Rocky Mountain Elk Forecast 2019

Roger Wheaton - September 20, 2019

Here's where the experts think hunters will find the biggest bulls this season.

Nothing is quite as right as losing oneself to Alaska's wild country in pursuit of a monster DIY moose. Hunting

Chasing Mammoths in the Alaskan Wilderness

Joseph von Benedikt - September 30, 2019

Nothing is quite as right as losing oneself to Alaska's wild country in pursuit of a monster...

See More Big Game

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Game & Fish subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now