Pompano with Pickled Peppers Recipe

Award-winning chef Rob McDaniel pairs fresh pompano with some pickled peppers and toasted breadcrumbs for a little smoky goodness with just the right amount of sweet heat.

Pompano with Pickled Peppers Recipe
Each summer, family vacations and fishing trips to the coastline along the Gulf of Mexico often result in a cooler of fresh pompano destined for the dinner table. Use the filets from these tasty fish for this Pompano with Pickled Peppers Recipe!

For David Bancroft, the memories are simply golden as he reflects on childhood years spent along the Gulf Coast fishing with his grandfather.

Those early morning wake-up calls would produce adventures to the beach where the search for sand fleas would take place, bait for the tasty fishing goodness to come. After a few hours of soaking the bait in the surf line, a collection of saltwater pompanos was ready to head for the family dinner table.

Bancroft, of course, is the host of ExMark’s excellent Prime Cuts series on backyard cooking. And as he remembers his southern heritage and the cooking greatness that it fueled, he pairs up in this cooking lesson with longtime hunting, fishing, and cooking brother Rob McDaniel to see what delicious success the pair can whip up next.

No stranger to cooking successes, Bancroft is a four-time James Beard Award semifinalist in the Best Chef South category, Iron Chef Showdown Champion, and owner of the Acre and Bow and Arrow BBQ restaurants all of this not far away from his beloved Auburn University.


McDaniel is known for his cooking successes too, since he’s a five-time James Beard Award semifinalist in the Best Chef South category along with being a longtime executive chef at one of Alabama’s most well-known restaurants, Springhouse. Add in the fact that he once bested Bobby Flay in Iron Chef competition and you know that bringing these two outdoors and cooking enthusiasts together again is about to produce another recipe designed to bring about some backyard cooking greatness!


To create McDaniel’s superb recipe, start with a Gulf Coast favorite, some fresh pompano fillets where the skin is left on. Keep in mind that this recipe also works well with just about any type of oily fish the Gulf can produce from pompanos in the surf to cobia and Spanish or King mackerel caught out deeper around the oil rigs and sunken reefs.

With the fillets in hand, pour a small amount of peanut oil onto them, oiling each side with your fingers. A pinch of salt and some freshly ground black pepper is a good finishing touch before flipping the fillet and repeating the process on the opposite side. One note of caution here from McDaniel is to avoid using too much oil, which can leave a hint of burnt oil flavor on this dish if you overdo it.

After getting the fillets ready, you’ll want to place them skin-side down on the Green Egg grill that Bancroft uses in his backyard kitchen. Note that the grill should be ripping hot, as he likes to say, heated to 600 degrees. Once the fish is on the grill, don’t touch it or reposition it since you want the skin to quickly cook and get nice and crispy.

When the fish has cooked skin-side down for a few minutes—and when the fish gets opaque and has nice white edges to it—you’ll want to flip it and finish it on the other side for a minute or two.


When cooked properly skin-side down, the skin will caramelize and tighten up to a crispy surface that should release easily from the grill’s hot surface. When done correctly here, the fish fillet can be easily flipped with nothing more than a fork being used.

Do note here that while the grill marks add a little bit of visual appeal and help produce the charring flavor, the point of the crispy skin is to properly cook the fish above it. The high heat—which Bancroft notes many top chefs use these days—is designed to cook the meat or fish quickly so that moisture is retained. With lower heat, the cooking process can be slowed enough that moisture is unwittingly drawn out of the dish, leaving it too dry.

After the fish fillet has cooked, let it rest for a few moments while you go to work on the additional portions of McDaniel’s recipe. You’ll want to finely slice up some red onion, putting it into a small metal mixing bowl along with some fresh garlic.


Into that mixture, add the pickled peppers—McDaniel uses aji dulce peppers, Jimmy Nardello peppers and jalapenos—and gently whisk it all together. By the way, Bancroft notes that the pickling brine will break down the onion a little bit, giving the mixture a semi-crunchy texture that combines some sweet heat as well.

Next, ladle the pepper mixture onto a plate. Then put the Gulf Coast favorite, the pompano fillets, onto the pickled peppers and onion. Finally, it’s time for the toasted breadcrumbs to be sprinkled on the top of the fillet, a topping that McDaniel creates from the crumbs of homemade ciabatta bread along with some parsley, some chives, some butter, and a few other spices too.

When this saltwater fish recipe is finished up, the result is a clean-tasting, simple dish that provides dinner guests with some texture and flavor changes along with some smoky, sweet heat goodness that is literally popping with flavor.

Not to mention a few wonderful memories of Gulf Coast fishing adventures made in previous years with your loved ones and friends!

Rob McDaniel’s Pompano with Pickled Peppers Recipe

Video courtesy of Exmark’s Backyard Life

Serves: 2
Prep time: 15 minutes
Cook time: 20-30 minutes

Ingredients:

  • Pompano fillets
  • Peanut oil
  • Salt
  • Pepper
  • Pre-toasted breadcrumbs
  • Pre-pickled peppers
  • Fresh garlic
  • Red onion

Directions:

  1. To start, clean and fillet your pompano. Apply a light coat of peanut oil, salt, and pepper to both sides.
  2. Heat your grill to 600 degrees.
  3. Place the pompano fillets skin-side down on the grill. Allow the fillets to cook until they’re nice and crispy on one side—essentially the whole way through on the skin side—to achieve nice grilled char marks. Once the scales and skin are nice and crispy, flip and allow the flesh side to briefly cook. Then, remove the pompano from the grill and allow it to rest while you prepare the other ingredients.
  4. Ready your pre-toasted breadcrumbs.
  5. Ready your pre-pickled peppers. McDaniel uses a variety of in-season peppers— aji dulce, Jimmy Nardello and jalapenos. And, he adds a little fresh garlic and red onion for this recipe.
  6. Prepare your final dish by lining the bottom of your plate with pickled peppers. Then, place a healthy portion of breadcrumbs on top of your pompano before placing it atop your pickled peppers.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

MLF Pro Tips: Go-To Baits for the Spawn

MLF Pro Tips: Go-To Baits for the Spawn

Major League Fishing pros talk about the first lure they choose when targeting spawning bass.

Yakgear Basic Kayak Angler & Deluxe Anchor Trolley Kits

Yakgear Basic Kayak Angler & Deluxe Anchor Trolley Kits

New products from ICAST 2020 included the Yakgear Basic Kayak Angler and Deluxe Anchor Trolley kits. Bill Bragman highlights the features of each kit.

Daiwa Tatula 300 Baitcaster

Daiwa Tatula 300 Baitcaster

The new Tatula reel is perfect when an angler is on the water fishing big baits for big bass!

Daiwa Saltiga Lever Drag Saltwater Reel

Daiwa Saltiga Lever Drag Saltwater Reel

In this ICAST Fishing Gear Guide video, Mark Mills with Daiwa and Florida Sportsman's Jeff Weakley talk off-shore fishing gear.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

On windy summer days when the crappie have gone to deep-water brush piles, what tips and tricks are necessary to catch a limit of slabs? Fishing How-To

How to Catch Summertime's Deepwater Crappie

Game & Fish Staff

On windy summer days when the crappie have gone to deep-water brush piles, what tips and...

As most catfish anglers know, blue cats, channel cats and flatheads will eat darn near anything that fits in their mouths. Catfish

5 Ways To Catch Catfish on Lures

Keith Sutton - September 16, 2015

As most catfish anglers know, blue cats, channel cats and flatheads will eat darn near...

30 awards presented (virtually) from the New Product Showcase. ICAST

ICAST 2020 Best of Category Winners

Game & Fish Staff - July 16, 2020

30 awards presented (virtually) from the New Product Showcase.

Here are the 10 most common spinning and baitcaster reel performance problems and how to fix them. Fishing How-To

10 Most Common Reel Performance Problems

Anietra Hamper

Here are the 10 most common spinning and baitcaster reel performance problems and how to fix...

See More Trending Articles

More The Grill

As the summer season arrives, so does the usual routine of grilling out cuts of beef, burgers, hot dogs and brats, but if you're hankering for some fish, give these grilled options a try. The Grill

Backyard Grilling: Tasty Fish Recipe Ideas for Summertime's Smoky Menu

Lynn Burkhead

As the summer season arrives, so does the usual routine of grilling out cuts of beef, burgers,...

Award-winning chef Rob McDaniel pairs fresh pompano with some pickled peppers and toasted breadcrumbs for a little smoky goodness with just the right amount of sweet heat. The Grill

Pompano with Pickled Peppers Recipe

Lynn Burkhead

Award-winning chef Rob McDaniel pairs fresh pompano with some pickled peppers and toasted...

If you haven't grilled fish or wild game on a wooden plank before, it's easy to do. Here are some tips on how to prepare a plank for the grill, along with some cooking options. The Grill

Tips for Plank Cooking Wild Game on the Grill

Tiffany Haugen

If you haven't grilled fish or wild game on a wooden plank before, it's easy to do. Here are...

Looking for a fine way to spend a summertime evening? Then clean the freezer out, find a whole venison backstrap, fire up the grill, and follow this recipe from Andy Morgan. The Grill

Grilled Whole Venison Backstrap Recipe

Lynn Burkhead

Looking for a fine way to spend a summertime evening? Then clean the freezer out, find a whole...

See More The Grill

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All Game & Fish subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now