How to Best Hunt Whitetails in the Midwest

I remember each hunt with a fresh mind. That old brute I killed with the Winchester .350 Legend in Missouri. The main-frame 10-pointer with the split brow that I arrowed on the edge of a cut cornfield in South Dakota. The old, sly deer that got away in Illinois. That 180-inch monster I spotted at a distance on public land in Kansas. Of course, I’ll never forget all the bucks that I’ve killed in Kentucky and Ohio (my two primary deer hunting states), and even more, all the big ones that got away.

I’ve hunted all over the Midwest, including Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Missouri, Ohio and South Dakota. Each of these destinations was unique in its own right. Of course, each one was vastly different in terrain, topography, habitat types, whitetail genetics, hunting pressure, hunting dynamics and more.

No matter where you decide to hunt in the Midwest, though, it’s important to have the right mindset, use the correct tactics, and genuinely deploy a good game plan. Here’s some of what you should know before deer hunting in a Midwestern state of your choice.

Start with Proper Expectations

The first step in hunting the Midwest is having the proper expectations. Without question, this region is known for its incredible whitetail pursuits. After all, it’s the crowned jewel of the record books, which is largely due to great agriculture, soil, habitat, mineral, genetics, culture and more. Deer reach old enough age classes to sport massive racks, and deer hunters dream of hunting the Midwest for that reason and much more.

Despite the promise of big deer, hunters must temper what they expect out of the hunt. Just because it’s the Midwest doesn’t guarantee a massive buck or even a filled tag. Your hunt is only as good as the property you plan to hunt. Furthermore, many variables influence the hunt, including weather, temperature, food sources, other hunters and general deer behaviors. For reference, I’ve had my fair share of magical Midwestern hunts, as well as plenty of true duds.

Some midwestern states require drawing a tag, and others are over the counter. For example, Iowa and Kansas are the most famous for using a tag drawing system. The Hawkeye State is typically a four-year draw for non-resident bowhunters, and in the Sunflower State, it’s typically a two-year wait. Of course, other states such as Illinois, North Dakota and South Dakota implement draw systems, too. In contrast, other states in the region, such as Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, Ohio and Wisconsin, are over-the-counter states, meaning you can simply buy a license and tag and do not have to draw one.

Without question, as collective states, draw states tend to offer better hunting, because these typically have better-regulated hunting on the statewide level. This method limits the number of non-resident hunters, reduces the buck harvest and improves the buck age structure. In turn, this leads to an increased number of older (and bigger) whitetail bucks on the landscape.

Don’t shy away from over-the-counter states, though. Indiana, Minnesota, Nebraska, Ohio and Wisconsin all have excellent deer hunting reputations. Furthermore, these routinely rank high on Boone & Crockett records lists, regardless of metrics used or how you spin the data. After all, Wisconsin is still the No. 1 state in the nation for record-class deer.

Overall, expect to have a good deer hunt, but don’t go into it thinking you’re taking a Boone & Crocket whitetail home. Chances are you won’t. That’s a rare deer, even in the Midwest. But that doesn’t mean you can’t dream, set goals or enjoy whatever outcome your Midwestern deer hunt produces.

Implement the Proper Mentality

Every region and state in the nation offers a different type and style of hunting. Each hunt requires a different approach, physically and mentally. Be mentally, physically and emotionally prepared for your upcoming hunt. Do that, attune your mental prep to the trip, and you’ll be in a much better place.

Understand Habitat Dynamics

Each region, state, county and property poses a completely different set of habitat, terrain and topography variables. The Midwest is no different. Thus, it’s crucial to study the habitat dynamics within the general and specific properties that you’ll be hunting.

For example, is it a mix of agriculture and timber? Flat or rolling hills? Dry ground or marsh and swamp? Does it have water access via lake or river? There are so many things to study and learn via app, map and in-person scouting.

Realizing these things helps hunters make better hunting decisions. The habitat type impacts tactical decisions, approaches implemented and much more. Therefore, study the habitat to make better decisions before and during the hunt.

In addition to the general region, study the habitat type on the specific property as well, as it factors into the specific decisions made while hunting. It also greatly influences the exact hunting spots, entry routes and exit paths.

Scout with Regional- and Property-Specific Factors in Mind

Every hunt includes a host of regional and property-specific factors. The aforementioned habitat type is only one of many examples. Other regional factors include general hunting pressure, season date timing and rut timing, among other things. Property-centric factors include bedding cover, food sources, water sources, hunting pressure, etc. Before and even during the hunt, scout for the situationally minded elements that virtually always play into the hunt.

Capitalize on Morning Feed-to-Bed Patterns

Midwestern whitetails exhibit strong morning movement, especially during the latter portions of the pre-rut and rut. Oftentimes, you can catch deer traveling back into thicker cover along feed-to-bed patterns. Additionally, during the rut, you might intercept bucks as they cruise between doe bedding areas and along the downwind sides of bedding areas. Regardless, morning hunts can be dynamite.

Camp Out on Afternoon Bed-to-Feed Routes

Likewise, midwestern whitetails often display great fidelity to their feeding patterns. Thus, it’s important to hunt afternoons when these are best, such as during the early season, early pre-rut and late season. That said, continue to camp out on afternoon bed-to-feed routes during the latter days of the pre-rut and throughout the rut.

Use Midwest-Centric Deer Hunting Tactics

Each region of the country and habitat type tends to require or at least be better attuned to certain deer hunting tactics. Oftentimes, calling, rattling and decoying are more effective in this region than in any other. Also, in areas with more topography, morning and afternoon thermals play a bigger role in the hunt. Where water is present, water thermals factor in as well. All said, implement Midwest-centric deer hunting tactics that apply to the specific properties you plan to hunt.

Consider Situational Deer Hunting Tactics

Oftentimes, we outdoor writers, hunting show hosts, deer hunting influencers and other media personnel speak of deer hunting tactics in terms of absolutes. These are the general rules to follow, but the exceptions are far more common than typically noted.

Furthermore, deer hunting is very situational. Deer hunters must observe each unique scenario and apply decisions and tactics that are best for each hunt. For example, the specific approach and tactics used might vary significantly from one day to the next, even in the exact same stand location.

Implement Mobile Deer Hunting Methods

One of the most underutilized deer hunting tactics is being mobile. Far too often do deer hunters get stuck in the rut of their predetermined beliefs, concepts, ideas and overall plans. When hunting Midwestern whitetails, consider being appropriately reactive to what you see and hear in the field.

Are deer using a trail 75 yards away rather than the one you’re camped out on at 20 yards? Make a move and re-hang your treestand. Is it dead on your ridge, but you can hear all manner of deer commotion on the next one over? Climb down and head over there. Seeing bucks be aggressive or all-out fighting? Consider calling, rattling and decoying. Whatever the instance, be mobile and willing to change your specific hunting spot, hunting tactics, etc.

Be Appropriately Aggressive

Another common mistake deer hunters make? Being much too passive in their deer hunting approach and decision-making. Instead, they should be appropriately aggressive in the days hunted, methods deployed, tactics used, etc. Choose your shots, so to speak, and know when to make the right moves. You’re likely only in the Midwest for a few day. So, make bold moves and fill your precious buck tag.

Bag Your Buck

If you’ve never hunted the Midwest and plan to, you’re in for a treat. It’s a unique experience, and with a well-planned trip to a moderate to good destination, you should have a wonderful time. Bagging a big Midwestern buck is no easy feat, though. These deer aren’t pushovers. But these big-bodied, heavy-antlered whitetails certainly are full of big-time deer hunting fun. I hope you experience a deer hunt for the ages upon your maiden voyage to the land of whitetail dreams—the American Midwest.

---

---