Best Crappie Fishing in the Northeast As Summer Approaches

Springtime in the East brings plenty of excitement for outdoor enthusiasts, with turkey hunting and trout fishing often stealing much of the spotlight. But for those in the know, it’s also prime time for white and black crappies as they prepare for the spawn—a brief yet crucial period that offers some of the best (and tastiest) fishing opportunities of the year. For trophy crappie anglers, this is one of the most important windows to target the biggest fish of the season, as larger females move into the shallows, making them more accessible than at any other time of year.

As water temperatures rise above 55 degrees, crappies instinctively begin to move in to spawn. Males take the lead, clearing out circular nests in 2 to 6 feet of water near submerged brush, stumps and vegetation. Once the nests are prepared, females arrive to deposit thousands of eggs before retreating, leaving the males to fertilize the eggs with their milt and then guard the eggs and newly hatched fry. The spawning phase typically lasts 2 to 3 weeks, with peak activity occurring during stable weather conditions. Sudden temperature swings or passing cold fronts can disrupt the process, causing fish to become inactive or retreat to deeper water.

CRAPPIE FISHING IN THE SPRING

The crappie spawn offers a prime opportunity to target these prized paper-mouthed panfish in ultra-shallow, cover-filled waters. Springtime fishing can be fast-paced and action-packed, as crappies tend to school up near perennial spawning areas—where there’s one, there are often many. This concentration of fish creates high-percentage fishing opportunities, where multiple large crappies can be caught in a single outing.

Males, in particular, become highly aggressive, eating just about anything that appears to threaten their nests, making for fast limits and easy fish fries. Understanding the spawn not only helps anglers catch bigger fish but also encourages selective harvest, ensuring healthy crappie populations for future seasons.

In the East, we’re lucky to have an abundance of quality crappie waters, from natural lakes and vast river systems to the countless ponds and backwaters that dot the region. However, for dedicated crappie anglers, three key zones stand out, offering not only solid action but also a good chance at catching a true slab.

NUTMEG STATE NIRVANA

The Litchfield Hills, nestled in the northwest corner of Connecticut, feature rolling terrain, picturesque views, charming small towns and excellent crappie fishing.

“You will catch plenty of crappies, and you will certainly be surprised at all the other species that will be caught in the process,” says Buzz Brannon of Fishing Quiet Waters (fishingquietwaters.com), a premier guide service in the region.

For crappie anglers, key waterbodies in the area include Bantam Lake, West Twin Lake, East Twin Lake, Tyler Lake and Candlewood Lake. The crown jewel is undoubtedly Bantam Lake, where anglers can expect crappies to measure around 10 inches long on average. A bonus of fishing Bantam Lake is its reliable white perch population, which frequents the same areas as the crappies. The same massive northern pike that attract hardwater anglers each winter are never far behind.

For Brannon, water temperature is the key indicator for crappie activity. “We like to see the water temps hit around 60 degrees for reliable action,” he says.

Covering water is essential. Many days—even during the spawn—are kicked off by trolling with small Rapala baits and soft-plastic swimbaits before slowing down to comb the most productive areas with a range of slip-bobber-and-jig combinations and small live baits fished on or near the bottom.

EMPIRE STATE EXCELLENCE

While it might not compete with Southern powerhouses like Florida or Mississippi, New York holds its own among the nation’s top states for crappies. With its abundance of inland lakes, access to two Great Lakes and the mighty Saint Lawrence River, New York has no shortage of quality habitat or good panfish anglers.

I caught up with Nick Petrou, an outdoor journalist and the owner of Natural Outfitters (516-306-2954), where he leads multi-species adventures on the Finger Lakes, Lake Ontario and Lake Erie. With a background in saltwater fishing around Long Island, you might think it takes a giant tuna or striped bass to get Nick excited, but he takes great pride in his springtime crappie fishing. According to Petrou, the two standout crappie fisheries in Western New York are Honeoye Lake and Silver Lake.

“Both lakes produce impressive numbers of quality crappies,” he says. “While other area lakes and bays of Lake Ontario have decent populations, Honeoye and Silver offer the ideal conditions for the species to thrive.”

While both lakes do have deeper basins, there is no shortage of spawning structures like standing timber, docks, inflows, outflows and plenty of vegetation.

While many anglers in the area stick to fishing grass lines and spawning flats with live bait, Petrou takes a different approach. He targets spring crappies around vegetation that has yet to green up after winter, where fish gorge on aquatic insects and arthropods seeking shelter in the decaying plant matter.

“Just like bluegills, crappies do a lot of pecking,” he says. “When they’re keyed in on micro forage, keeping presentations as small as possible is critical.”

To keep his live well full, Petrou relies on subtle plastics like the Maki lineup from Clam rigged on jig heads. As the water warms and small shiners become a larger part of the crappie’s diet, he turns to forward-facing sonar to locate isolated schools just off spawning areas. There, he targets bigger fish with a classic jig-head-and-shiner combo.

GRANITE STATE GO-TOS

Southern New Hampshire offers a distinct beauty, characterized by rolling forested hills dotted with numerous lakes and ponds. Kaleb Brown, who grew up in the area, made a name for himself on the college fishing circuit as a 4-year member of the fishing team at Lander University in South Carolina. Today, while he continues to compete in tournaments and work within the outdoor industry, Brown gets home as often as he can to chase trophy crappies.

Southern New Hampshire boasts several large bodies of water known for producing sizable crappies, such as the Connecticut River to the west and Massabesic Lake to the east. However, Brown is particularly drawn to the lesser-known spots in between.

“From the Vermont state line to the seacoast, there are endless small lakes and ponds that are completely loaded with crappies,” he says.

To efficiently assess these waters, Brown applies his bass fishing expertise from ice-out through the spawning season. At ice-out, he employs LiveScope technology to scan expansive main-lake basins for suspended schools, simultaneously inspecting shallow flats where crappies gather to feel spring’s first warm rays.

As water temperatures climb into the mid-50s and the crappie spawn gets moving, Brown experiences top action. “I look for vegetation in 5 feet of water,” he says. “Most of these lakes have muck bottoms, so any clean, hard spots with a hard sand bottom are productive."

Brown particularly enjoys watching a slip float get dunked by a willing crappie with the feed bag on. Nevertheless, when fish are on beds and sight-fishing opportunities present themselves readily, he transitions to micro drop-shot rigs and super-light Ned rigs, which always make for a truly fun—and tasty—day on the water.

SPAWN-TIME SETUPS

• The best baits and rigs for spring crappies.

Soft-plastic baits like curly-tail grubs and paddle-tail shad are highly effective during the crappie spawn because their natural, lifelike swimming action mimics small baitfish or aquatic invertebrates, making them irresistible to the aggressive males defending their nests. When rigged on a jig head, often 1/8- or 1/16-ounce in weight, these baits can be slowly retrieved through shallow, cover-rich areas where crappies are spawning, helping anglers locate fish through a reaction-style presentation.

Another option is the classic slip-float-and-jig combo, which is an excellent choice for picking apart productive areas and quickly catching the most active crappies present. The slip-style floats allow anglers to easily present the jig at varying depths. For jigs, I suggest looking at hair jigs tied with high-quality bucktail or marabou, with pink, white and chartreuse all being great color options. For live-bait anglers, there likely is not a crappie technique more effective than suspending a fathead minnow or chunk of crawler under a float.

I recommend anglers use two tackle setups during the spawn. The first is a light or ultra-light spinning combo with a 6- to 7-foot rod and a 1000-size reel for light jigs, small floats and detecting subtle bites. For a more versatile option, a medium-light spinning combo with a 7-foot or longer rod and a 2500-size reel is ideal for swimbaits and other soft plastics. The added power is helpful, as pike and bass are always a welcome addition to a day spent beating the banks.

---

• This article was featured in Game & Fish magazine. Click to subscribe

---