Collapse bottom bar
Your Location: You're in the jungle, baby! X
Bluegill Fishing Kansas Nebraska

Hot Spots for Kansas and Nebraska Crappie

by Mike Gnatkowski   |  February 21st, 2012 0

Rick Dykstra admires a stringer of spring specks. The flesh of spring crappies is white, firm and delicious. Photo by Mike Gnatkowski.

It pays to be flexible if you’re an outdoorsman. Even though you might have a game plan, Mother Nature can throw you a curveball that requires you to go to plan B. That’s exactly what happened on a crappie trip to Kansas last spring.

Our initial plan was to fish Milford Reservoir, near Junction City, Kansas. The 16,200-acre reservoir is known as one of the better crappie waters in the state. An unusually cold spring, though, had delayed the spring crappie bite. The specks were still in deep water and scattered for the most part because of the weather. Blustery north winds and temperatures in the 50s meant fishing there would be tough. “I’ve got an idea,” stated my guide, Rick Dykstra, assistant director at the Geary County Convention and Visitors Bureau (, 800-528-2489). Dykstra keeps close tabs on the fishing activities in the area and always has a plan B to fall back on. “Meet me at my house in an hour. I know another place that we can go that should be sheltered where we can catch some fish.”

Dykstra had his boat hooked up when I arrived at his house. We jumped in and he pointed the rig to the southwest. On our route we passed 3,280-acre Council Grove Reservoir. The wind had turned Council Grove Reservoir to a muddy brown as we crossed the dam and waves and whitecaps were pushing their way down the lake. There wasn’t a boat in sight. Not far from Council Grove Reservoir, Dykstra pulled into the launch on 434-acre Council Grove City Lake. The lake is city-owned and located just west of Council Grove.

There was a noticeable difference in the wind. Cottages and a large row of cottonwoods protect the sheltered bay and the launch. Without the wind, the sun actually felt a little warm and, although we initially had coats on, it wasn’t long before we both were peeling them off.

“We’ll fish this little cove right off the launch to start,” suggested Dykstra. “It’s sheltered, shallow and it warms up pretty quick. There might be some pre-spawn crappies moving into here.” Because the lake was sheltered and smaller, the fishing schedule there was weeks ahead of the larger bodies of water in the area.

Dykstra didn’t even fire up the big motor and just used the trolling motor to ferry us across the cove where the sun was shining brightly on the shoreline and some docks. We each began flipping small twister-tail jigs up under and next to the docks. At about the third dock we fished I felt a subtle “tick” and set the hook. “There’s one!” I exclaimed as my light spinning rod bent double. I quickly hoisted about a 10-inch white crappie into the boat. A flip back under the same dock produced a twin. And then another.

Rick Dykstra has fished for bass competitively and the competitive bone was getting the best of him. “Let me see what you’re using there,” he queried as he strained to see the jig I was using.

“Silver sparkle with a pink head,” I said as I dangled the jig in front of him so he could get a good look. “1/16-ounce jig head.”

“That’s a lot smaller than the jig I’m using,” he contemplated. While Dykstra was rummaging around in his tackle box looking for a smaller jig, I added another speck, a white bass and a sheepshead to the tally. Dykstra only looked up and grinned. I always said I’d rather have the client catching the fish than the guide. Dykstra finally got another jig tied on and immediately caught three crappies on three consecutive casts. Touché!

You could see the wind whipping through the tops of the cottonwoods, but you could hardly feel it on the water. The warm sun gradually heated up the surface of the water and as it slowly climbed into the low 60s the fishing got even hotter. We just kept working up and down the docks. Several times we poked our nose around the point, but the wind and lack of fish brought us back into the cove. In addition to the crappies, we caught eight other species of fish. We hadn’t caught a walleye all day, but suddenly a school moved in and we caught a half-dozen in quick order and added a couple of them to the live well. The catch included white bass, saugeye, spotted and largemouth bass and plenty of hard-pulling drum. It was one of the best multi-specie fishing days I’ve ever had and all because we had a plan B.

Indeed, to take advantage of the great spring crappie fishing in the Great Plains states it pays to be flexible, have the boat on the trailer and be ready to travel to find the best fishing. If you can do that, you can turn a hot two-week crappie bite into a long two months of great fishing.

“There’s a big difference between when the crappie spawn occurs between north and south,” stated Kansas Department of Park and Wildlife Fisheries Biologist Chuck Bever. “In the middle part of the state, when the water reaches between 60 and 65 degrees, you can count on the spawn to begin. That may be May 1st or later in the north, but down in southeast Kansas it might be two weeks sooner or more.”

Bever said that many factors work to determine exactly when the crappie spawn takes place. “It depends on the depth, water clarity and the size of the lake,” he said. Some years, anglers might be fishing for pre-spawn crappies in open water on the southeastern lakes when others are still ice-fishing on Glen Elder.

Bever said that two southeastern reservoirs produce consistent crappie action. “Fall River and Hillsdale are two of the better crappie waters in that part of the state,” said Bever. Both have a lot of brush and flooded timber, so they warm up quickly. There’s usually some good fishing beginning in early March.” Twenty-five hundred-acre Fall River Reservoir is located near Fall River. During the last fisheries survey on the lake, 44 percent of the crappies captured were between 10 and 15 inches. Four thousand five hundred and eighty-acre Hillsdale Reservoir is located in eastern Kansas in Region 2, near Paola.

Bever admitted that pre-spawn crappies can sometimes be tough to find, but when you do they’ll be concentrated and you can do well. It’s usually sometime in April before the crappies move shallow and begin to spawn in earnest on these reservoirs. Again, 60- to 65-degree water temperature is key.

How big a lake is has a huge bearing on how fast it warms up and when the crappies turn on. Lakes just a short distance away, like Council Grove Reservoir and Council Grove City Lake, might produce a hot crappie bite a month apart. “It’s hard to predict exactly when the best crappie fishing will be on Council Grove Reservoir,” said Bever, “but it’s a good crappie lake year in and year out.”

Turbidity can be a huge factor on how quickly a reservoir warms up in the spring. “Melvern Reservoir is one that fishes well from early March right through the spring, but it warms slower than other reservoirs,” claimed Bever. “It’s a clear lake and clear lakes don’t warm as quickly as lakes that are turbid. They don’t absorb the heat.” Melvern Reservoir offers 7,000 acres of prime crappie habitat near Topeka. Melvern is also among the state’s best for smallmouths and walleyes, too.

“I would expect the northwest reservoirs to produce some good fishing this spring,” offered Bever. “They have had good water for a number of years.” Checkout Kirwin, Webster and Norton reservoirs for big slabs this spring. In the north-central part of the state, Glen Elder, Lovewell and Wilson generally produce hot spring speck action. Because of their size, clear waters and northern climes, these reservoirs generally don’t produce great fishing until early May and it extends well into June most years. Last year, when I fished these reservoirs in mid-May, the crappies weren’t even close to spawning and were nowhere near the shallows. Start in the southeast and finish up the spring on these northern reservoirs and you can enjoy more than two months of great fishing for papermouths.

For more information on angling opportunities, maps and licenses for fishing in Kansas, contact the Kansas Department of Wildlife, Parks and Tourism at or at (620) 672-5911.

Check out Nebraska hotspots for crappie on page two

Load Comments ( )
back to top